Active and passive management: what the fee buys
beginner
Automated material · TradeAlmanac editorial deskDraft prepared by a language model from our stored data; not reviewed by an editor.
An active fund promises a result better than the market. A passive one promises the market's result minus a small fee.
Arithmetic that does not depend on skill
All market participants together own the whole market, so their average result before costs equals the market's. After costs it is lower by exactly those costs.
It follows that active management on average loses to passive by the difference in fees. That is not an assessment of managers' competence but an accounting identity.
Why past results mislead
Out of a large number of funds, some will show a good result by chance. Selecting a fund on past returns means selecting luck along with skill, and luck does not repeat.
Besides, unsuccessful funds that closed disappear from the statistics, and the average result of the survivors looks better than reality — see Survivorship bias: why success statistics mislead.
When active management makes sense
In narrow, under-researched segments where an informational edge is attainable. And where no index exists at all.
What to choose
A passive approach as the base — The index approach: buying the whole market. Active decisions for the part of a portfolio whose loss you could explain to yourself as tuition.
Related instruments
Draft prepared by a language model from our stored data; not reviewed by an editor.
Model: claude-opus-5
How we use language modelsSimilar articles
- The secondary market for DFAs: why the asset never leaves its own platformA DFA can be sold before redemption only inside the platform where it was issued, and only through an exchange operator listed in the Bank of Russia register. Why the asset cannot be moved to another operator, how selling it differs from placing an order in a bond's order book, and what the sale changes in the purchase limit and in the tax.
- Terms of Trade: How the Ratio of Export to Import Prices Moves the Rouble and ProfitsThe terms of trade are the ratio between the prices at which a country sells its exports and the prices at which it buys its imports.
- TWAP order: the algorithm slices volume by time, not by liquidityA TWAP order (time-weighted average price) is an instruction to the trading system: take a large order, break it into a stream of small child orders and release them in equal portions at equal intervals until the end of a set window.
- The Impossible Trinity: What a Central Bank Pays for a Fixed Exchange RateThe impossible trinity is the proposition that, out of the set of goals "fixed exchange rate", "free movement of capital" and "independent interest rate", a state can hold any combination except the complete set.